Quick answer
For most families with younger children, or anyone who wants to play on the sofa, in bed and on the TV, the Nintendo Switch 2 is the easier pick. It costs least to keep running and has the strongest parental controls app. For teenagers and adults who want big cinematic games on a 4K TV, the standard PS5 with a disc drive is the best-value PlayStation. The PS5 Pro only makes sense if you already own a good 4K TV, play a lot, and don’t mind paying extra for sharper, smoother graphics.
Why the box price is only the start
Over two or three years, games, an online subscription, extra storage and, on PlayStation, a disc drive can easily cost more than the console itself. Prices have also moved this year. Sony raised the UK recommended retail price of every PS5 model from 2 April 2026, and Nintendo announced Switch 2 price rises in several regions from 1 September 2026. So check today’s price, and compare it with the RRP on the maker’s site.
Our Black Friday deals and gaming deals pages are the place to watch over the next few weeks. If a “was” price looks suspiciously high, read our guide to how “was” prices work in UK sales and run it through the deal checker.

The three consoles at a glance
|
PS5 (with disc drive) |
PS5 Digital Edition |
PS5 Pro |
Nintendo Switch 2 |
| Built-in storage |
1TB |
825GB |
2TB |
256GB |
| Disc or cartridge |
Ultra HD Blu-ray drive built in |
No drive; add-on drive sold separately |
No drive; add-on drive sold separately |
Game cards (some are game-key cards that download the game) |
| Storage expansion |
M.2 NVMe SSD (PCIe Gen4) |
M.2 NVMe SSD (PCIe Gen4) |
M.2 NVMe SSD (PCIe Gen4) |
microSD Express cards only |
| Plays on the go |
No (TV only) |
No (TV only) |
No (TV only) |
Yes: handheld, tabletop or TV |
| Picture |
Up to 4K on a TV |
Up to 4K on a TV |
4K with AI upscaling (PSSR), up to 120fps in supported games |
7.9in 1080p screen up to 120fps; up to 4K on a TV via the dock |
| Older games |
Most PS4 games |
Most PS4 games |
Most PS4 games, some with Game Boost |
Most Switch 1 games |
| Online play needs |
PlayStation Plus |
PlayStation Plus |
PlayStation Plus |
Nintendo Switch Online |
| Parental controls |
PlayStation Family app (free) |
PlayStation Family app (free) |
PlayStation Family app (free) |
Nintendo Switch Parental Controls app (free) |
| UK price |
Check today’s price |
Check today’s price |
Check today’s price |
Check today’s price |
Specs are from Sony’s and Nintendo’s official pages. Some storage is reserved for system software, so the usable space is always less than the figure on the box.
The hidden costs, one by one
Games
Games are the biggest ongoing cost. Nintendo’s own titles rarely drop much in price, while PlayStation games usually come down faster, and the PlayStation Plus Extra catalogue can replace buying many older games.
Second-hand discs are the traditional PlayStation saving, but Sony now says that from January 2028, newly released PlayStation games will be sold digitally only. Discs for games released before then will keep working. A disc drive is still handy for the big back catalogue of PS4 and PS5 discs, and for films.
On Switch 2, look out for game-key cards. They look like normal cartridges but hold only a key, so the game downloads when you first play it. You’ll need an internet connection and enough free storage, and the card has to be in the console each time you play.
Online subscriptions
On both platforms, most online multiplayer needs a paid subscription. Free-to-play games are the usual exception, but check each game.
PlayStation Plus comes in three tiers:
- Essential: online multiplayer, monthly games, cloud saves and member discounts.
- Extra: everything in Essential plus the Game Catalogue, a large rotating library of PS4 and PS5 games, and Ubisoft+ Classics.
- Premium: everything in Extra plus the Classics Catalogue of older PlayStation games, game trials, PS5 cloud streaming and the Sony Pictures Catalogue.
We couldn’t confirm current UK PlayStation Plus prices on Sony’s site, so check today’s price on playstation.com. The 12-month plans normally work out much cheaper than paying monthly.
Nintendo Switch Online is cheaper. When we checked Nintendo’s UK site on 14 November 2026, the 12-month prices were:
- Individual: £17.99
- Family (up to 8 accounts): £31.49
- Individual + Expansion Pack: £34.99
- Family + Expansion Pack (up to 8 accounts): £59.99
The basic membership covers online play, cloud saves, NES, Super NES and Game Boy classics, and GameChat on Switch 2. The Expansion Pack adds Nintendo 64, Game Boy Advance, SEGA Mega Drive and, on Switch 2, GameCube classics, along with some extra content for selected Nintendo games. The family plan is good value if more than one person in the house plays online.
Storage
The PS5 Digital Edition’s 825GB fills up fastest. All PS5 models take an extra M.2 NVMe SSD (PCIe Gen4). Sony says drives from 250GB to 8TB are supported, it recommends a read speed of 5,500MB/s or faster, and the drive needs a heatsink or other cooling. Check Sony’s support page for your model first.
The Switch 2 has 256GB built in and only accepts microSD Express cards. Ordinary microSD cards from an original Switch won’t run Switch 2 games, so budget for the newer, pricier card type if you plan to buy lots of digital games or game-key cards. You can search microSD Express cards on Amazon.
The disc drive question
The standard PS5 has a disc drive built in. The Digital Edition and the PS5 Pro don’t, but both can use Sony’s add-on Disc Drive. It plays PS5 and PS4 game discs plus 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray, Blu-ray and DVD, and it needs an internet connection to pair with the console the first time. If you think you’ll want discs, for second-hand games or films, the standard PS5 usually costs less overall than a Digital Edition plus the add-on drive. Compare the two on the day you buy.
Controllers and headsets
Most families also buy a second controller. For PS5 online play a headset helps, and three are currently on our deals pages:
If you’re buying for a Switch 2, check the product listing for compatibility before you buy.
Older games: backwards compatibility
PS5: Sony says over 8,500 PS4 games play on PS5, with a small number of exceptions. Some get Game Boost for smoother frame rates, and the PS5 Pro boosts some of them further. PS3 and older discs won’t play, though some older titles turn up in the PlayStation Plus Premium Classics Catalogue.
Switch 2: most original Switch games work, and Nintendo publishes a compatibility checker for the few that don’t run, or don’t run properly. Some Switch games have free or paid “Switch 2 Edition” upgrades. If your child already has a shelf of Switch cartridges, that alone can make the Switch 2 the sensible next step.
Parental controls compared
Both apps are free, and both are worth setting up on day one, before the console is handed over.
Nintendo Switch Parental Controls app (iOS and Android). It works with Switch 2 and the original Switch. You can set daily play-time limits, and Nintendo says these can only be managed through the app. You can restrict games by age, block or limit messaging, and control GameChat: players under 16 can only use it once a parent has set it up, chat only with friends a parent approves, and need approval for video chat. eShop spending is restricted through the parent’s Nintendo Account settings.
PlayStation Family app (iOS and Android). You can set daily playtime limits for each day of the week, and choose whether your child gets a reminder or is stopped when time runs out. Children can request extra time or access to an age-restricted game, and you approve or decline from your phone. You can also set a monthly PlayStation Store spending limit and manage who your child can talk to. Some games, Roblox for example, have their own chat settings that you’ll need to set separately.
If you’re already juggling screen time on other devices, our guide to choosing a kids tablet with parental controls covers the same habits from a different angle.

Which one for whom
Young children (roughly 5 to 11) and mixed-age families
Nintendo Switch 2. It’s portable, local multiplayer works with the included Joy-Con 2 controllers, and Nintendo’s own games are generally rated for younger players. The family Switch Online plan is cheap for a whole household. Always check the PEGI age rating on each game.
Teenagers
PS5 or Switch 2, depending on their friends. Online play is social, so the console their friends use usually matters more than the specs. Many popular teen games are on PlayStation, and teens who want big action, sports or racing games tend to lean PS5. For more ideas, see our Christmas gifts for teenagers.
Adults and keen players with a good 4K TV
PS5 Pro. The sharper upscaled image and higher frame rates show up best on a quality 4K, 120Hz-capable TV. On an older or smaller TV, most people won’t see enough difference to justify the extra cost. If your TV is due an upgrade too, our LED vs QLED vs OLED vs Mini LED guide will help.
Film fans and second-hand game buyers
Standard PS5. The built-in drive plays 4K Blu-rays and pre-owned discs with no add-on to buy.
Shared TVs and travellers
Nintendo Switch 2. It plays on its own screen, so a busy living-room TV is no problem.